Kate Middleton Apologizes for ‘Confusion’ Over Family Photo That Caused Controversy

The palace would not be drawn on what part of the photograph was altered. When AP issued a “kill notification” — writing in an alert to journalists that after “closer inspection it appears that the source has manipulated the image” — most attention focused on Princess Charlotte’s left hand.

Others have highlighted inconsistencies in the alignment of the sweater pattern on Prince Louis’ shoulder, as well as a jagged white line in the background near his knee.

The photograph of the Princess of Wales and her children, Prince George, 10, Princess Charlotte, 8, and Prince Louis, 5, was supposed to both thank well-wishers for their support during her recovery and reassure people about her ongoing recovery after a slew of social media-fueled conspiracy theories about her.

But, instead, by the end of the day, it had started a storm of social media queries, and legitimate questions by picture editors. The photograph was then later removed from the libraries of leading photo agencies who suggested it had been altered, principally around Charlotte’s hand.

It was the first official photograph of Kate, 42, since her abdominal surgery of January 16.

The princess had not been seen officially in public since Christmas Day but was photographed unofficially in a car being driven by her mother Carole Middleton last week.The princess had not been seen officially in public since Christmas Day but was photographed unofficially in a car being driven by her mother Carole Middleton last week.

Usually, it is Kate who takes the family photographs but, for the first time, it was William, 41, who shot the image. It was taken at Windsor, where the family lives, last week.

An AP spokesperson released a statement to The Telegraph saying, “The photo shows an inconsistency in the alignment of Princess Charlotte’s left hand.”

Later on Monday, William is set to step out at Westminster Abbey for the annual Commonwealth Day service. His father King Charles, who will not be at the annual service due to his ongoing cancer treatment, will be represented by his wife Queen Camilla.